Archive for the ‘Innocents’ Category

Shane Crum on COVID-19 behind bars.

Saturday, August 8th, 2020

For some time now, I have been corresponding with Shane Crum, an inmate in Marion, Ohio, whom I believe to be innocent.

Last April, a number of his emails referenced COVID 19 in Marion. He first mentioned COVID on April 1st:

“Bob, howdy again. I apologize for not responding before now. Sunday evening we got word that a staff member here tested positive for covid 19. On Monday, we went into lockdown. We still can move around our locks in the day room. We also still have access to the kiosk. Nevertheless, more inmates are in the housing unit all day, and many of them are using the kiosk more frequently. The whole thing is chaotic at best.

“What concerns me about all of this is that staff keep the inmates isolated from one another. However, they are the ones suddenly preparing our meals, washing our laundry, and roaming between the four quarantine zones. Yesterday, an officer came into the lock, emptied out our ice machine and had his entire upper body inside the ice machine. If this is going to come into this prison, they are the ones who will bring it in here, and they are taking no precautions to keep the staff from spreading it to the inmate population. It is as though they are under the impression that the inmates will have it before they will, and we will give it to them. This is all very backward.”

On April 10th:

“Bob, howdy. How are you today? I do hope you and your family are well and staying safe. The virus is currently at this institution. I have repeatedly attempted to tell staff that they will be the ones who bring it in here, and that they should be mandated to wear the masks. It took them up til last week to mandate that. The staff are still creating policies that indicate the inmates will give it to the staff and not the other way around. They have been handling our food without wearing masks, our laundry (the same), mail, and they keep coming into the block and getting ice out of our ice machine without wearing a mask, gloves or both (when the inmates should be the ones touching all these items and not staff). A virus spreads by mucus droplets that come from the mouth and nose, and through contact with that mucus. They do not seem to get it. What do you expect, I am just an inmate to them and I could never know more than they do. I do not think they realize they are liable for what happens to us. According to the Federal Courts, we are wards of the state, and they are suppose to protect us from such things. I am done ranting.”

On April 20th:

“Howdy Bob. How are you today? I am truly sorry I have not replied to your last e-mail until now. On Thursday the 16th, OSU came in and tested the entire institution. We now know 1828 inmates here have tested positive for covid 19. Needless to say, I have been a little distracted.”

And then on April 28th:

“Bob, howdy again. Well, the whole institution was tested for covid 19 on the 16th. They finally informed the inmate population on the results of those tests on the 23rd. 2100 out of approximately 2500 have tested positive here. From your e-mail, I would think you are aware of the conditions here. Anyway, I tested positive. I had a couple days where I was really down. I did not eat for three days straight. I did not have any major symptoms, so it was like being really tired with extreme headaches, and dizziness. I pulled through it without much of a problem. Most of the inmates here had similar symptoms, but some are not doing too well. From the beginning, the news reported that around 80% of the people who get infected with the virus would show mild to no symptoms. While that was promising, the other 20% where getting hospitalized and some dying. I am thankful that I did not go through what some of the other inmates are dealing with. The staff here are still running some bizarre procedures that will ensure the eventual infection of the entire population here. What I am really not understanding is that our administration has been negligent at best and O.D.R.C. continues to transfer inmates here. They keep separating the negatives from the positives, but that seems to be some sick way to ensure they will eventually infect the inmates who tested negative. The National Guard are great and efficient. Way better people than the C.O.s who work here. I keep asking them about some of these procedures the administration have put in place, and they are just as dumbfounded as I am. I wish I could tell you I am staying safe, but the staff are ensuring that is impossible for us. That is enough of the pitty party stuff.”

You can learn more about Shane by visiting his web site: https://shanecrum.org.

Please help him if you can. He would most appreciate just hearing from you: https://shanecrum.org/contact-us/.

-Bob

A prison post from my friend Shane Crum

Sunday, August 2nd, 2020

https://shanecrum.org/2020/08/02/two-thoughts-from-shane/

Learn more about his case at his web site.

You can send him a message or make a donation.

 

Funeral Services for Bruce Perkins

Friday, July 24th, 2020

Carol called me this afternoon. She sounded very tired. But reconciled that Bruce was finally at rest.

She does regret Bruce not ever getting to meet so many of his friends before he left. I told her we all knew and loved Bruce, the kind man, the gentle giant, the good friend. We didn’t need to physically meet him.

We, who know the story, and how he endured, with grace, 30 years of the slings and arrows of cruel and outrageous fortune, rose above it with his dignity intact, and at least got out of the Texas hellholes for the last year of his life, —-we admire the perseverance, his courage, the integrity, his faith and trust in his Lord,—-the strength and love of Carol, his wife who stood by him all those years. Brave, tough folks.

Carol asked me to forward along the information re Bruce’s funeral service.

He’ll be waked at:

Corley Funeral Home
418 N. 13th St.
Corsicana, TX 75110

(Funeral Home Phone: 903-874-3755)

Service to begin at 2 PM, Saturday, August 1, 2020.

Frank Kane, NCRJ Clerk-Treasurer

Joseph Allen Parole Hearing

Thursday, July 23rd, 2020

The NCRJ has been sponsoring the case of Joseph Allen since 2004.

It is a terrible case. Joseph was once even freed, with no restrictions, for a number of years after a judge ordered his acquittal. But the corrupt forces that railroaded him into prison refused to let that stand, and persuaded the Ohio Supreme Court to lock him up again.

Here is more information about the case from the NCRJ website.

Joseph will have a parole hearing in December. He is most anxious that supporters write letters of support.

Here is guidance from Joseph’s lawyers:

No longer than a page

  • a little bit about their background, such as their job, where they live, etc.
  • how they know Joseph/history of relationship;
  • describe any positive things they know about Joseph, such as his character, his accomplishments, specific examples of good things that he has done, improvements they have seen in his character over the years, etc.;
  • describe how they would support Joseph if he is released, whether emotional, economic, spiritual, job offer, etc.

Letter should be addressed to “Members of the Ohio Parole Board.”

You can mail your letter:

Attention Ricky Parsons
Kravitz, Brown & Dortch, LLC
65 East State Street #200
Columbus OH 43215-4277

You can also email it to Ricky Parsons <rparsons@kravitzllc.com>.

Thank you for your support of Joseph.

-Bob Chatelle

John Swomley has taken the case of Paul Litchfield

Thursday, July 23rd, 2020

Boston attorney John Swomley, the lead attorney of the team that freed Bernard Baran, is now working to free another innocent Berkshire county prisoner, Paul Litchfield. Please visit Paul’s website:

https://paullitchfield.webs.com/

And consider making a donation.

-Bob Chatelle

The Case of Shane Crum

Sunday, July 19th, 2020

For several months, I have been corresponding with an Ohio prisoner named Shane Crum.

I have come to believe in his innocence. If you’d like to learn more, here is his web site:

Shane’s Story

It is a most difficult case, and his family’s resources are exhausted. To proceed, they are trying to raise some money.

You can donate to his defense fund at his web site.

-Bob

Great News in the Wilcox-Aldridge Case!

Friday, June 19th, 2020

“COLUMBUS —
The state of Ohio will pay $1.2 million to M. Jenny Wilcox and Robert Aldridge, former Huber Heights residents who were wrongfully convicted in 1985 of 23 child molestation charges and told it’d be 60 years before they’d be eligible for parole.

“Wilcox, whose last name is now Reach, will receive $726,315, while Aldridge will be paid $527,255, according to a settlement approved Monday by the Ohio Court of Claims. The state will pay another $646,430 to Cooper & Elliott, the law firm that represented the two.

“Wilcox and Aldridge appealed their convictions and had them overturned in March 1996 — after spending 11 years in prison. The highly sensational case fell apart after it was determined that key information was withheld at trial, testimony was coerced and the state was aware of the possibility that its child witnesses were committing perjury. Three witnesses later recanted as adults.”

Read the article in the Dayton Daily News.

Gross police and prosecutorial misconduct contributed to their wrongful conviction.

Here is a summary of the case from the Dayton Daily News and the entry in The National Registry of Exonerations.

Many allies of the National Center for Reason and Justice made significant contributions to fighting this injustice, including Private Investigator Martin Yant, Dr, Richard Ofsche, Dr. Melvin Guyer, and NCRJ Advisor, Dr. Elizabeth Loftus.

Congratulations to them all, but especially to Jenny Reach and Richard Aldridge!

A life of Shame

Friday, November 22nd, 2019

[Angela Piazza/for Statesman]

“What do you do when you are 25 years old and a county like Williamson County comes after you and you don’t have any money?”

–Troy Mansfield

A chilling case of cruel and unusual prosecutorial misconduct. Read the article by Tony Piohetski in the Austin American-Statesman.

h/t Bill Dobbs of the Dobbs Wire.

The Wrongful Conviction of Bruce Perkins

Saturday, September 21st, 2019

eric hexheimer/houston chronicle

“Swept up in a wave of extraordinary child sex abuse claims in the 1980s and early 1990s, prosecutors across the country charged dozens of parents and caregivers with appalling-sounding acts despite scant physical evidence. Suggestive, leading questioning by untrained police and counselors produced outlandish accusations, including claims of bizarre satanic rituals. Yet an unshakable belief that even young children always tell the truth yielded lengthy prison sentences.”

Read the article by Eric Dexheimer in the Houston Chronicle.

How Confirmation Bias Sends Innocent People to Prison

Saturday, July 27th, 2019

(innocence project)

“While cases like these often feature wrongdoing by individual prosecutors and police officers, a new study suggests the problem is deeper. After analyzing 50 wrongful convictions and other investigative failures, Texas State criminologists Kim Rossmo and Joycelyn Pollock found that confirmation bias, reinforced by groupthink and strong incentives to quickly identify the perpetrators of highly publicized crimes, figures prominently in the mistakes that send innocent people to prison.

“Once police decide they have the right suspect, Rossmo and Pollock report in the Northeastern University Law Review, they tend to develop “tunnel vision” that obscures other possibilities. They become focused on building a case against the person they’ve decided is guilty, ignore or minimize countervailing evidence, and interpret ambiguous evidence in a way that supports their initial conclusions.”

Read the article by Jacob Sullum in Reason.